Recognizing the Concept of »Judgement« with a Comparative View | ||
| مجله علمی "حقوق خصوصی" | ||
| Article 5, Volume 20, Issue 2, October 2023, Pages 243-255 PDF (695.06 K) | ||
| Document Type: Research Article | ||
| DOI: 10.22059/jolt.2024.368760.1007247 | ||
| Authors | ||
| Hassan Mohseni* ; Behnam Shekoohi Mashhadi | ||
| Department of Private and Islamic Law, Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran | ||
| Abstract | ||
| The most important Judicial Act are crystallized in the form of "Judgement", but the previous (approved 1939) and current (approved 2000) Civil Procedure Law, as well as other related current laws, despite referring to this judicial act and even its examples in numerous articles, are devoid of any presentation the definition is about this. Therefore, the current research aims to identify the concept of " Judgement" with a descriptive-analytical method and with a comparative view, it examines the existing criteria to answer the question, what is the criterion for recognizing this act? Several criteria, both formal and substantive, have been presented to distinguish judicial acts from other (Administrative) actions in other countries, especially in France, which are the criteria for placing any one of them alone is not the answer to the problem as it should be. On this basis, in this research, while presenting the meaning of "Judgement" from a lexical and idiomatic point of view, we introduce and analyze the aforementioned criteria to reach the selected criteria. The findings of the present research indicate that a judicial act is considered a "Judgement" if it is issued by a judicial authority decisively and with the characteristic of being sued regarding a dispute arising from an uncertain legal situation. | ||
| Keywords | ||
| Judgement; Opinion and Decision; Substantive and Formal Criteria; Ruling Decisively; Judicial Acts | ||
| References | ||
|
جعفری لنگرودی، محمدجعفر (۱۳۵۱). دانشنامۀ حقوقی. تهران: ابن سینا. ج 2.
دریانوش، فرشید؛ طجرلو، رضا؛ رضویفرد، بهزاد (1400). ضوابط و آثار تفکیک عمل قضایی از عمل اداری قضات و مدیران قضایی قوۀ قضاییه. حقوق اداری، س 8، ش 27.
دهخدا، علیاکبر (1373). لغتنامۀ دهخدا. چ اول از دورۀ جدید. تهران: مؤسسۀ انتشارات و چاپ دانشگاه تهران. ج 7.
رضایینژاد، امیرحسین (1401). نگارش رأی قضایی. چ 2. تهران: شرکت سهامی انتشار.
شمس، عبدالله (۱۳۸۷). آیین دادرسی مدنی، دورۀ پیشرفته. چ 17. تهران: دراک. ج 2.
ـــــــــــــ (۱۳89). آیین دادرسی مدنی، دورۀ پیشرفته. چ 16. تهران: دراک. ج 3.
صدرزاده افشار، سید محسن (۱۳۷۹). آیین دادرسی مدنی و بازرگانی دادگاههای عمومی و انقلاب. چ 5. تهران: ماجد.
کاتوزیان، ناصر (۱۳۹۲). اعتبار امر قضاوت‌شده. چ 9. تهران: بنیاد حقوقی میزان.
متین‌دفتری، احمد (۱۳۹۸). آیین دادرسی مدنی و بازرگانی. چ 6. تهران: مجد.
محسنی، حسن (1391). مفهوم مرجع قضایی در نظام قضایی کشور. دادگستری، د 76، ش 79، 99 ـ 123.
محسنی، حسن (1392). آیین دادرسی مدنی فرانسه. تهران: شرکت سهامی انتشار. ج 2.
محسنی، حسن (1393). ادارۀ جریان دادرسی مدنی. چ 3. تهران: شرکت سهامی انتشار.
محسنی، حسن و رضایینژاد، امیرحسین (1398). امکان صدور «رأی شفاهی» و ارزش «اعلام رأی» در حقوق ایران، فرانسه، انگلستان و امریکا. تحقیقات حقوقی، د 22، ش 87.
محسنی، حسن و میرشکاری، عباس (1393). تحلیل انتقادی نظر ارشادی دادرس در دادرسی مدنی. مطالعات حقوق خصوصی، د 44، ش 2، 225ـ 239.
مصدق‌السلطنه، محمد (۱۳۹۶). دستور در محاکم حقوقی. تهران: شرکت سهامی انتشار.
معین، محمد (1362). فرهنگ فارسی معین. چ 5. تهران: امیرکبیر. ج 2.
نهرینی، فریدون (۱۴۰۰). آیین دادرسی مدنی، فرایند دادرسی و صدور رأی. چ 2. تهران: گنج دانش. ج 3.
Cadiet, L. (2010). Code de procédure civile. Paris: Litec.
Cadiet, Loïc et Jacques Normand, Soraya Amrani Mekki (2010). Théorie générale du procès. Paris: Puf.
Campbell Black, Henry M.A. (1990). Black’s Law Dictionary. 6th ed. West Publishing.
Capitant, H. (1936). Vocabulaire Juridique. Paris: Less presses universitaires de France.
Curzon, L.B. (2002). Dictionary of Law. 6 editions. Long Maul.
Daryaoosh, F., Tajarlo, R., & Razavi-Fard, B. (2021). Criteria and effects of separating judicial act from the administrative act of judges and judicial managers of the judiciary. qjal, 8(27). (in Persian)
Dehkhoda, A.A. (1994). Dictionary of Dehkhoda. first edition of the new period. Tehran: University of Tehran Publishing and Printing Institute. Vol. 7. (in Persian)
Edward, A.H. (1999). A Matter of Jadgment, not a Matter of Opinion. New York University. Vol. 7.
Fricero, N. (2004). L'essentiel de la Procédure civile. 3e édition. Paris: Gualino Editeur.
Georges de Leval (2005). Eléments de procédure civile. 2e edition. Belgique: Larcier.
Gifis, S.H. (2003). Law Dictionary. 5 edition. Barron’s Library of Congress Catalog-in-Publication Date.
Glasson, E., Moral, R., & Tissier, A. (1992). Theorique et Partique d, Organisation Judiciaire, de Competencet de Procedure civil, Tom Troisieme, Troisieme ed, Librairie du Recueil Sirey.
Guinchard, S. & Debard, T. (2017). Lexique Des Terms, Juridiques. 24 Edition. Paris: Dalloz.
Guinchard, S., Ferrand, F., & Chainais, C. (2009). Procedure civile. Paris: Dalloz.
Hacknd Blockwele, A. (2008). The Essentionall Law Dictionary. Sphinx Publishing.
Jafari Langroudi, M.J. (1972). Legal Encyclopedia. Tehran: Ibn Sina. Vol. 2. (in Persian)
Jolowicz, J.A. (2008). On Civil Procedure. Cambridge University Press.
Katouzian, N. (2013). Res Judicata in civil litigation. 9th edition. Tehran: Mizan Legal Foundation. (in Persian)
Lebivits, G. (2010). Judgement Writibg in Kenya and the Common-Law World. Kenya Law. Vol. 2. KLR.
Lefort, Ch. (2007). Procédure Civile. 2e edition. Paris: Dalloz.
Loughlin, P. & Gerlis, S. (2004). Civil Procedure. London: Cavandish Publishing.
Matin Daftari, A. (2019). Civil and Commercial Procedure. 6th edition. Tehran: Majd. (in Persian)
Mohseni, H. & Mirshkari, A. (2014). Consultative view of judge in civil trial. Private Law Studies Quarterly, Vol. 44, No. 2, 225-239. (in Persian)
Mohseni, H. & Rezainejad, A. (2019). Comparative Study of Oral Judgment Rending Possibility and Declaration of Judgment in Iran, France, England & U.S.A. Journal of Legal Research, Vol. 22, No. 87. (in Persian)
Mohseni, H. (2012). The Notion of Jurisdiction in Iranian Judicial System. Judicial Law Journal, Vol. 76, No. 79, 99-123. (in Persian)
Mohseni, H. (2013). Civil Procedure of France. Tehran: publishing company. Vol. 2. (in Persian)
Mohseni, H. (2014). Administration of civil proceedings. 3 edition. Tehran: Publishing Company. (in Persian)
Moin, M. (1983). Persian Dictionary of Moin, Intermediate. Vol. 2. 5 edition. Tehran: Amirkabir. (in Persian)
Mossadegh Al-Saltaneh, M. (2017). Order in Legal Courts. Tehran: Publishing Company. (in Persian)
Nahreini, F. (2021). Civil Procedure. 2nd Edition. Tehran: Ganj Danesh. Vol. 3. (in Persian)
Rezainejad, A.H. (2022). Judicial Judgment Writing. 2nd edition. Tehran: Publishing Company. (in Persian)
Rose, W., Sime, S., & French, D. (2006). Blackstone's Civil Practice. Oxford.
Sadrzadeh Afshar, S. M. (2000). Civil and Commercial Procedures of Public and Revolutionary Courts. 5 edition. Tehran: Majd. (in Persian)
Shams, A. (2008). Civil Procedure, Advanced course. 17 edition. Tehran: Derak. Vol. 2. (in Persian)
Shams, A. (2010). Civil Procedure, Advanced course. 16 edition. Tehran: Derak. Vol. 3. (in Persian)
Sime, S. (2005). A Practical Approach to civil procedure, 8 edition. Oxford.
Vincent, J. & Guinchard, S. (1994). Procédure Civile, Pixhuiteme Edition. 23 e. Paris: Dalloz.
Vincent, J. (1976). Procédure Civile. Paris: Dalloz. | ||
|
Statistics Article View: 1,021 PDF Download: 457 |
||